Vossler, Joshua; Watts, John; and Hodge, Tim, "What is a Scholarly Article?" (2011). Kimbel Library First Year Experience Instructional Videos. 9.
https://digitalcommons.coastal.edu/kimbel-library-instructional-videos/9
Thank you to Vanderbilt University's Peabody Library.
Created by Eli Moody, 2007.
Thank you to VCU Libraries!
A scholarly periodical requires that each article submitted for publication be judged by an independent panel of experts (scholarly or scientific peers). Articles not approved by a majority of these peers are not accepted for publication by the journal. Peer-reviewed articles are generally considered to be scholarly and reliable resources.
How do I tell the difference between scholarly articles, popular articles, and trade articles?
From the University of Maine at Farmington: Guide to identifying scholarly sources
Scholarly Journals |
Magazines |
Professional / Trade Journals |
|
Written by |
scholars / researchers |
journalists |
journalists / industry experts |
Written for |
professors, students |
general public |
people who work in that field |
Looks like |
mostly text, may have charts |
glossy covers, many advertisements, |
glossy covers & industry specific ads |
Articles |
contains original search/analysis |
info about current events, trends, pop culture |
report on industry news & trends |
Examples |
Studies in Short Fiction |
Time * Newsweek |
RN * Accounting Review |